IsItAGoodCar
Reliability Guide

Common Problems with the
2005 Rover CityRover

For the 2005 model year, MG Rover introduced the 'Mk II' CityRover featuring upgraded standard equipment, revised suspension tuning, altered gear ratios, and substantial price reductions before production abruptly ceased in April 2005.

What changed for 2005

  • •Introduction of updated 'Mk II' specification with revised suspension springs and shock absorbers.
  • •Revised gearbox ratios for quieter motorway cruising and improved urban fuel economy.
  • •Upgraded interior upholstery fabrics and standard CD audio head unit across all trims.
  • •Official list price reduced by up to £900 across the range to improve sales competitiveness.

Common MOT watch-outs

  • !Excessive play in front lower wishbone ball joints and steering rack inner tie-rod ends.
  • !Rear brake drum shoe imbalance and binding handbrake cable mechanisms.
3
Known Issues
1
Serious
2
Moderate
0
Minor

All Known Issues

Flexible Brake Hose Degradation and Hydraulic Leakage

SeriousBrakes

The CityRover's flexible rubber brake hoses degrade, crack, and perish at an unusually rapid rate on UK roads, severely accelerating brake fluid contamination and leading to sponginess in pedal feel. On the annual UK MOT test, perished and bulging brake hoses represent one of the single most frequent failure categories for surviving CityRover models. Left unaddressed, deteriorated hoses risk fluid leaks under hard emergency braking, leading to partial brake loss and MOT test failure.

Est. Repair Cost: £120–£280
Warning Signs:

Spongy or excessive brake pedal travel, Visible surface cracking and perishing on flexible brake hoses, Dropping brake fluid level in the reservoir, Immediate failure during annual MOT brake efficiency inspection

What to Inspect:
  • Inspect all four flexible rubber brake lines with a torch for cracking or bulging under pressure
  • Check brake fluid reservoir level and colour for dark contamination
  • Test pedal firmness with engine running; pedal should not creep towards the floor
Verified by IsItAGoodCar Research TeamUpdated

Remote Key Fob Desynchronisation and Engine Immobiliser Lockout

ModerateElectrics & Electronics

The factory remote central locking key fobs on the CityRover are notorious for losing their synchronisation code with the onboard immobiliser module, particularly when the fob battery runs low or the main 12V battery is disconnected. When desynchronised, the immobiliser remains stubbornly engaged, cutting the fuel injection and starter circuits and stranding the vehicle. Resynchronising requires a specific manual key-turn sequence or dedicated diagnostic reprogramming, which many general garages lack.

Est. Repair Cost: £80–£220
Warning Signs:

Engine cranks but fails to fire, or starter completely inhibited, Key fob buttons fail to lock or unlock the central locking, Rapidly flashing engine immobiliser warning lamp on the instrument cluster, Intermittent alarm triggering when unlocking the driver's door manually with the key

What to Inspect:
  • Test both supplied remote key fobs multiple times to verify reliable locking and starting
  • Ensure the immobiliser warning lamp extinguishes within three seconds of turning the ignition on
  • Ask the seller for the emergency key access (EKA) security code card
Verified by IsItAGoodCar Research TeamUpdated

Front Suspension Wishbone Bush and Ball Joint Wear

ModerateSuspension & Chassis

The CityRover's front lower suspension wishbone bushes and integrated ball joints wear out quickly under typical UK urban driving over speed cushions and potholes. Although engineered in India for rough surfaces, the rubber compounds in the wishbones degrade rapidly in wet and salt-laden UK conditions, creating noticeable knock sensations through the floor and vagueness in steering precision. Replacing worn wishbones requires pressing out bushes or swapping complete arm assemblies.

Est. Repair Cost: £150–£350
Warning Signs:

Clunking or knocking noises over road ripples and speed humps, Uneven tyre tread wear on the inside edges of the front tyres, Vague steering response and noticeable wandering under straight-line braking, MOT advisory or failure for excessive play in lower suspension joint

What to Inspect:
  • Listen for dull thuds from the front wheel arches when traversing rough surfaces during test drive
  • Inspect the front tyres for asymmetrical shoulder scrub or inner edge wear
  • Lever the lower control arm against the subframe to check for degraded rubber bushes
Verified by IsItAGoodCar Research TeamUpdated

Buying Tips for 2005 Rover CityRover

  • Mk II models from late 2004 and 2005 offer slightly better ride quality and improved gear ratios.
  • Confirm the emergency key access (EKA) security code is present in the handbook documentation.